Do they work?
Do they embarrass you as a insurance professional?
Are the national Insurance agent organizations doing enough to keep up with the geico’s and the Progressives of the world?
First off, they must be driving home a point, or I would not be addressing it. If the point is to remember Geico and progressive and State farm then it is working, I remember each of their messages and who is doing what.
Direct writers:
- Geico- we will save you 15%. But 15% off what? What is the
coverage? They never talk about coverage just price. Are they intimating that they can save you the traditional 15% commission your broker gets? For Christs sake, they are using a lizard and a caveman to sell me. I am smarter than that, but apparently millions of Americans are not.
- Progressive. Not sure what their message is? I guess it is savings through bundling. Again, I am not buying their crap that they are
selling from Flo, who looks like a wise cracking waitress.
- Allstate- I get their message a bit better. They have a classy pitch man and they talk about some very unique coverage enhancements.
- Amica, liberty and State farm all have messages, but it is a lot of Blah, Blah, Blah
I do not know what I am more tired of, either the Insurance ads, or the endless ads about erectile dysfunction. At least I know what the Viagra people are selling. If I take this little blue pill, then I am going to get _____.
So with =out the buying power of these giants, Agents are left to advertise locally in the paper, or the radio. We tend to go with the I am very serious message, and if you insure with me, I will take really good care of you. I think that message falls on deaf ears.
So what about the trusted choice ads? They are generic, and to be honest with you, I cannot remember one of them. So I guess they are not effective.
The moral of the story, is unless you are filthy rich with a ginormous advertising budget and a Manhattan ad agency, you might be better off thinking of another way to get your message out to the populace.
A focused sales effort through the internet and through social networking along with solid community service might be the best route to go.